Saturday, July 31, 2010

book review: Becoming Raw


The authors of Becoming Vegetarian and Becoming Vegan have come together again to write Becoming Raw, by authors Brenda Davis, RD, Vesanto Melina, MS RD, with Rynn Berry. Thank you, Book Publishing Company, for providing me with a copy to read and review. This book is chock-full of nutritional information and other essentials to successfully eat a raw vegan diet.

When first "becoming raw" myself, I was hard-pressed to find a raw book without a particular agenda or type of raw eating style that it pushed above the rest. And raw recipe books were helpful, but without enough nutritional information to be thorough enough for a curious newbie. I notice new-to-raw eaters often go online to ask information of people in forums who had been eating raw longer than them, but sadly get conflicting or poor advice. I wish all raw newbies had Becoming Raw for reference.

Becoming Raw covers the following, and more:
  • the history of the raw food movement (great for history buffs)
  • a few reasons to eat raw, without being pushy
  • evidence of healing on the raw diet, mentioning specific health conditions
  • which nutrients are met with raw foods and where the raw diet might fall short
  • enzyme theory
  • recipes to get you started
  • meal plans for daily raw eating: both simple meals and recipe-oriented ones
Reading Becoming Raw was like a crash-course in nutrition. I learned all about carbohydrates, fats, protein, and vitamins, yet wasn't forced to read about foods that I am ethically opposed to, like meat or dairy. It had been awhile since learning about nutrition, so getting a refresher was helpful. The book contains several detailed charts of raw foods and their nutrient levels.

The authors already assume that you are on board with being vegan or raw, so they don't spend tons of time being preachy about it. The authors also seem to realize that not everyone is interested in being 100% raw, so they provide meal plans for adding in some healthy cooked vegan food. This would also be helpful for people who are transitioning to a raw diet but still including some cooked food.

Since I personally feel like most of my nutrient needs were being met on a raw/high-raw diet, this book simply reassured me I am on the correct path. I eat lots of veggies, fruits, nuts and seeds and supplement for vitamin D and B-12. I did learn a bit more about fatty acids and feel assured that since I eat plenty of hemp and chia that I am covered. I really appreciated that the book dose not vilify either fruit or fat. The authors do cite research that shows raw foodists on a low-fat diet have had deficiencies, but include meal plans for how to eat a lower-fat diet but include some fatty acids for optimum health.

The research in this book is solid. The authors cite studies from various sources, which is unlike any other raw book I have read. The authors admit the diet has shown a few negative results, and discuss why and how to remedy this. Having a science background, I appreciated this empirical approach. However, there admittedly needs to be more research on the subject.

A downside is the book is rather thick and there is a lot to absorb, and I found myself rereading to understand more complex bits. But a savvy reader will know how to skip around to find the pieces of info he or she needs. I also did not find the recipes very stimulating or interesting at first glance, given I have many other recipe books to enjoy, however I do have some bookmarked to try in the future. (If you are curious, Lisa reviewed several.)

Raw foodists have had too few resources to get solid nutritional advice. No longer! Becoming Raw should be on the shelf of all raw and high-raw foodists.

17 comments:

griffen said...

looks like i need to go pick this up. ;)

griffen said...

looks like i need to go pick this up. ;)

Averie (LoveVeggiesAndYoga) said...

oh what a stellar review for this book..I have it too. I dont read it that much b/c as you said, it's very thick/dense but as you said, it's CHOCK full of great empirical info..which depending on one's mood and needs can be good...or a little thick :)

i love how it's not preechy and also assumes you are raw or on board to a large extent

i have to say, most books are SO dogmatic they are a total turnoff and for many ppl who "need a book" to help them wade thru things, they get lost and give up b/c of the dogma. Sad but true.

questions to me...
kombucha. After I seal the bottles i sometimes let them go another day or so on my counter, sometimes not. just depends how bitter/sour it already was and if it's already well on its way, i pop into the fridge.

recipe fail from another blogger...oh as hard as it would be, i would WANT to know! You're not some bozo who can't cook and doesnt know how to sub in or out various ingredients..you CAN cook so if you failed at it, id want to know. But i realize some ppl would rather live in the ignorance ether :)

Elizabeth said...

Great review. Based on what you wrote, I really want to read this book.
Peace and Raw Health,
E

Ela said...

Thanks so much for this review: it's really helpful.

Great to hear of a book that provides solid nutritional info _and_ isn't preachy! What a good combination!

I liked how you said that it felt good to you to be reassured that you were on the right track: I think that that sense of validation is an important part of the role these books play.

For me, density isn't necessarily a drawback - as you said, one can use it as a reference book and skip around.

It's interesting that you said the recipes weren't inspiring: is it just me, or is that usually the case in a 'general' book as opposed to a dedicated recipe book? In this kind of book, I tend to think of the recipes as really just being 'exempli gratia' and that they almost expect you to go elsewhere for the real gold.

Many thanks!
love
Ela

Nikki said...

I'm so glad that you reviewed this book. I keep seeing it around, but I'm a really visual person, and the cover isn't very appealing to me. I know, lame excuse, but I tend to pass over food books if the covers don't pull me in. Maybe now I'll give it a chance, especially knowing that it has good nutrition info.

Isle Dance said...

I'm so glad you shared this with us - fab!

Tough Cookie said...

Cool! Thanks for sharing!

I just put up a blog post about some big spiritual awakenings I had about my healing before I went into the hospital. I think you might enjoy it!

Sending you love and healing xoxo

Gena said...

I'm 100% with you on BECOMING RAW. I read every word and think that it's precisely the sort of balanced, SCIENCE and RESEARCH based work that the raw community needs more of. I give it two thumbs up -- I simply never remember to post book reviews, darn it!

VeganLisa said...

Hey Bitt,
I'm really glad you enjoyed the book. I still turn to it when I have nutrition questions - it remains a really important reference in my library. I wish I had this book when I started eating mostly raw 3 years ago.

Lauren said...

Looks like a great book! I am going to add it to my wish list! :) Thanks for the review!

Earth Mother said...

I knew you'd love it! (glad you decided to go ahead and share your review)

This book definitely has a permanent spot in my home library. I find that I use it as a reference book quite often.

HiHoRosie said...

It's on my shelf! It is a very informative book and agree there's a lot to absorb. Things I never knew! I tried a couple of the recipes - one was "eh" and the other was good (of course, left to my own interpretation :)). Great review you shared!

Rick said...

great book review. i'll recommend it to those considering raw, but you've helped me realize i probably don't need to buy it myself.

Michelle said...

I'll have to add this to my library list. Thanks for the review.

evergreen said...

Sounds like a great book to recommend to friends who might be raw-curious :) Thanks for the review!

Alissa said...

sounds interesting...i might have to get that one..